Hot take: fenders felt like overkill for a 2 mile ride to the shop
I figured a 12 minute ride each way was short enough that rain just meant getting a little wet, so I skipped them for 6 months. Last week I got caught in a downpour here in Portland and showed up to work with that cold stripe up my back, and I ordered a set that same night. Any cheap fender picks that fit a bike with no mounting holes?